Story Published:
Jul 8, 2005 at 11:05 AM PDT
Story Updated:
Aug 31, 2006 at 2:00 AM PDT
SALEM, ORE. - Same-sex couples would get most of the legal
benefits of marriage under a civil union bill easily passed Friday
by the Oregon Senate.
The measure was approved on a 19-10 vote after more than two
hours of often-passionate debate, but appears doomed in the
Republican-run House.
Chuck Deister, spokesman for House Speaker Karen Minnis, said
there are no plans to bring the bill to a vote in that chamber.
Two GOP senators joined 17 Democrats in passing the bill, which
would also outlaw discrimination based on sexual orientation in
housing and employment. The measure has the support of Democratic
Gov. Ted Kulongoski.
After the Senate vote, Kulongoski drew cheers and applause from
dozens of gays and lesbians who traveled to the Capitol to listen
to Friday's Senate debate.
Kulongoski, at an appearance with Senate sponsors of the bill,
called on the crowd to lobby the House Republican leaders to allow
a vote on the issue.
"The House has to deliver this bill," Kulongoski said. "Let's
go and tell the House, `we want this bill before we go home."'
Oregon voters in November passed a state constitutional
amendment banning gay marriage.
But Senate Majority Leader Kate Brown, a self-described
bisexual, said civil unions are "fundamentally and legally
different from the institution of marriage."
Foes of the bill disagreed, saying such unions are marriage by
another name.
Republican Sen. Jeff Kruse of Roseburg called the measure
"another step down the road to Armageddon" and questioned whether
pedophiles will want equal rights.
"This is dangerous ground, colleagues," he said. "This is a
blatant attempt to overturn the will of the voters."
Vermont and Connecticut have passed civil union laws, while
Massachusetts is the only state allowing gay marriage.
Ben Westlund of Bend was among the two Republican senators who
voted for the bill.
"We are on the front lines of the civil rights struggle of this
generation," said Westlund.
"One of the freedoms that should be afforded to all human
beings is the freedom to form families," he said.
But Sen. Charles Starr, R-Hillsboro, said the development of
same-sex families "is a vast untested experiment" that often
leaves children without fathers.
He said homosexuality is not "an immutable characteristic"
that justifies special rights for gays.
Democratic Sen. Alan Bates, an Ashland physician, said growing
scientific evidence shows that homosexuality is not a choice.