TALLMANSVILLE, W.VA. - As the victims' families made plans
for the first of the funerals, officials worked Friday to purge the
Sago Mine of poisonous gases and allow investigators to determine
what sparked the blast and how the miners spent their final hours.
Workers began drilling three ventilation holes into the mine.
But International Coal Group chief executive Ben Hatfield said it
could be days before the first investigators go in.
"There are so many things we don't know about what went
wrong," Hatfield said. "We don't want to put any more people at
risk until we know answers."
The Mine Safety and Health Administration appointed an
eight-person team to investigate Monday's blast that killed one
miner immediately and left 12 others trapped more than two miles
inside. Only one miner was alive when they were found nearly 42
hours later, huddled together behind a plastic curtain erected to
keep out deadly carbon monoxide.
Investigators said they are looking into all possibilities,
including suspicions that lightning ignited naturally occurring
methane gas or coal dust. Even before the blast, those were areas
of concern at the mine, which had been cited for violations in 2005
regarding the ventilation plan to control dust and explosive gases.
The accident took place after the mine had been closed for the
holiday weekend; the explosion was believed to have originated in
an unused section of the mine.
Mine safety experts said gas can build up in a mine after just
one day of idled operations, especially in the winter, when the
barometric pressure drops. Also, the metal casings of abandoned
natural gas wells above a mine can conduct an electrical current
into the ground.
"If this is in fact a strike of lightning onto a well, gas or
oil, that sits above an abandoned section of the workings, that
well should have had a substantial barrier to avoid this," said
David McAteer, who oversaw MSHA during the Clinton administration.
"We've had lightning strikes cause accidents in mines, and they're
very disconcerting because they do just what this did. They go down
and blow the seals out."
A federal report in 2001 documented at least seven instances in
the 1990s alone of methane or coal dust being ignited by lightning,
three of those in one mine in Alabama.
"I've heard those theories, but we have no concrete evidence
one way or another," said Bob Friend, MSHA's acting deputy
assistant secretary of labor for mine safety. "Nothing has been
dismissed."
Friend said when the mine is safe to enter, the team will
examine every aspect of it, including its physical structures and
all equipment. They will be looking for the direction of the
explosive forces. They will take dust samples. They will seize any
equipment that might have contributed to the blast and, if
necessary, test it in a lab.
The investigation will also involve interviews with dozens of
people, including the approximately 13 minors who escaped, workers
on previous shifts, and managers, Friend said.
The sole survivor's recollections could prove crucial. But
26-year-old Randal McCloy Jr., was believed to have brain damage
from oxygen deprivation and remained in a medically induced coma
Friday at the Pittsburgh hospital where he was moved a day earlier
to receive intensive oxygen treatments.
Dr. Richard Shannon suggested rescuers reached McCloy just in
time, because it appeared that in his last hour or so in the mine,
he lost the ability to sneeze and cough, and his lungs began to
fill with coal dust and the low-lying gases as he lay on his side.
In hopes of jogging McCloy back to consciousness, his family
planned to play the music of his favorite country artist, Hank
Williams Jr.
The probe will also look at the miscommunication from rescuers
inside the mine that led anxious relatives to believe for three
hours that their loved ones had miraculously survived. That period
of confusion was reflected in 911 tapes, in which emergency workers
were heard discussing the false report.
In what officials said appeared to be chatter between two
ambulances, one emergency worker said: "You might as well just
stand still right where you're at, Gary. They did find them, and
they're all OK, I guess, so, I think we might be transporting them.
I'm not exactly sure, but we're stuck right here."
When asked how many to prepare for, the other said: "Twelve,
and they're bringing them out."
In other developments, autopsies were completed and the bodies
of the miners were returned to the families. State law prohibits
the public release of autopsy results. Asked about speculation
among the families that the 11 trapped miners died from carbon
monoxide, state Health Department spokesman John Law said only: "I
don't think it will be a great surprise."
The first funerals for the fallen miners were being scheduled,
with at least three services planned for Sunday.
The Sago Baptist Church, which was a gathering place for
families during the vigil for the trapped miners, has become a
shrine, with flowers filling the tiny altar.
They included a vase with 13 red roses, one for each of the
miner's families, and a basket of peach-colored roses and daisies
from a mining shift in Alberta, Canada. To the right of the altar
was a large spray of snapdragons, carnations and chrysanthemums
from a woman in Galt, Calif.
"I want you to know that there are thousands, probably millions
of people who mourn with you and pray for you," said an
accompanying letter from Jennifer Coumbs. "People you have never
met are at this time asking the Lord to be with you to strengthen
you and hold you in His hands."