Story Published:
Mar 19, 2006 at 10:13 AM PST
Story Updated:
Aug 31, 2006 at 2:14 AM PST
RUSTON, WASH. - Asarco is poised to sell its waterfront
property that includes a toxic tomb of bricks, mortar and soil
saturated with arsenic, but some question who will be left with
remaining cleanup costs.
Lacey developer, MC Construction, is ready to buy the site.
However, it's expected to assume responsibility for only half of
the estimated $45 million in cleanup work that remains, including
as many as 500 contaminated residential yards, adjacent industrial
properties and nearby aquatic lands.
Asarco was once a Fortune 500 company that in 2005 filed for
Chapter 11 bankruptcy. If allowed to walk away from some of the
nation's most expensive environmental cleanups, it would leave
taxpayers with more than $1 billion in obligations - a low
estimate, some regulators say.
Ruston and Tacoma represent just a fraction of Asarco's cleanup
nationwide. As part of its bankruptcy filing, the company disclosed
that state and federal officials hold it responsible for
contamination at 94 sites in 21 states.
Asarco set up an environmental trust fund three years ago as
part of a settlement with federal regulators. Over the next five
years, it is expected to provide $62 million, plus interest. In
contrast, individual smelter cleanups typically cost about $200
million.
Distribution of the trust fund is prioritized based on human
health risks, making the Pacific Northwest sites less pressing.
Areas at the top of the list:
-Omaha, Neb., site of largest residential lead cleanup in the
United States.
-El Paso, Texas, contamination from a mothballed smelter and its
800-foot smokestack extends into Mexico and New Mexico.
-Hayden, Ariz., a still- operating Asarco copper smelter has
polluted its surroundings.
The Asarco bankruptcy was among the 10 largest filed in the
nation in 2005 and its list of creditors is long.
Officials with the Environmental Protection Agency had yet to
confront a polluter that sought to unload its cleanup
responsibility midway through the process - until Asarco.
"We're in uncharted waters," said Kevin Rochlin, the EPA
manager overseeing the $180 million Tacoma cleanup. "There has
never been anything of this magnitude and this complexity."
Cleanup remains at dozens of sites in the West and Midwest,
where Asarco maintained mining and metal extraction operations for
more than a century. Those places, in some cases entire towns, are
now some of the nation's largest Superfund sites.
In Idaho, for example, Asarco is among the mining companies
blamed for contamination spread across the 1,500-square-mile Coeur
d'Alene River basin. Cleanup is likely to last for generations, and
the EPA has estimated the cost of the first 30 years at $359
million.
In Omaha, Asarco ran a lead smelter and refinery on 23 acres
along the west bank of the Missouri River for more than 120 years.
It shut down in 1997, and in 2003 was designated a Superfund site
after blood tests detected dangerously high levels of lead in
hundreds of children.
The Omaha site encompasses 20 square miles, but could expand
because the boundaries of the lead contamination haven't been
mapped. The budget for the first five years of cleanup work is
$77.4 million. The EPA also has ordered the Union Pacific Railroad
to pay.
"By the time we're done, total site costs could be more than
$200 million," said Bob Feild, an EPA manager for Omaha.
Other places sullied by Asarco's mining and smelting operations
include East Helena, Mont., and Everett, where state Ecology
officials estimate 550 residential properties are contaminated with
arsenic.
In Ruston, the EPA added a smelter site there to its national
Superfund priorities list in 1983. Asarco has denied state
regulators' allegations that its smokestack spread arsenic and lead
contamination over 1,000 square miles. Damages could be included in
the state's bankruptcy court claim.
In the Tacoma area, cleanup estimates have topped $33 million
for residential soil removal, cleaning the slag peninsula where the
Tacoma Yacht Club stands and dredging the yacht basin and capping
other contaminated sediments in Commencement Bay.
After Asarco's bankruptcy filing, the EPA tapped Asarco's $100
million nationwide trust fund to continue the residential cleanups
in Tacoma, which in the first three years of distributions received
$16.6 million.
It remains questionable whether what's left of the trust will be
enough to satisfy Asarco's creditors and the needs of unfinished
cleanup.